5 Key Takeaways from a Bad Tenant Situation

Being a landlord isn’t just about bricks and mortar — it’s about people. That was the mindset of a kind-hearted couple in Nova Scotia who rented out their only property, offering it below market value to support new Canadians, retirees and individuals with special needs.

They paid for heat, water and electricity out of their own pockets. They didn’t just want to make money — they wanted to make a difference.

But what started with good intentions ended in heartbreak. After the first month, the tenant stopped paying rent. Police were called to the property several times. By the time an eviction order came through, the damage was already done — literally. The doors and roof were wrecked, and the couple was left emotionally and financially drained.

The damages are worth 5000 dollars according to the report.

Here are five key lessons from their experience, along with professional advice on how landlords can protect themselves without losing their compassion.

1. Tenant Screening Is Essential, Not Optional

It’s easy to want to give someone a chance, especially when your heart is in the right place. But not every tenant is ready for that trust. Skipping proper screening can cost you more than just rent.

Advice: Always do your due diligence and proper tenant screening. Check credit history, ask for references, speak to past landlords and verify income. A little time upfront can save you months of stress later on.

2. Keep Records, Not Just Receipts

One reason some landlords struggle to resolve issues quickly is because they don’t have the right documentation when problems arise. Even if you have the best intentions, paperwork matters.

Advice: Document everything — lease agreements, payment records, maintenance requests, photos of the property before and after move-in. If a tenant stops paying rent or damages your property, these records can make or break your case.

3. Know the Law, and Speak Up When It Fails You

In this case, the eviction process took far too long, even though the situation clearly qualified as urgent. The landlord said the system felt one-sided, and that legislation made it harder to act quickly.

Advice: Stay informed about your rights as a landlord. Read up on the Residential Tenancies Act, join local landlord groups, and don’t be afraid to push for fairer legislation. When enough voices speak up, change is possible.

4. Always Budget for the Unexpected

This couple offered affordable rent and covered the utilities, but when things went wrong, the financial loss was heavy. The experience has left them unwilling to ever rent again.

Advice: Always build a buffer into your budget. Set aside a portion of your rental income for emergencies like repairs, legal fees or unpaid rent. And consider landlord insurance — the right policy can help cover costly damages.

5. Lead With Compassion, But Set Clear Boundaries

The most painful part of this story isn’t just the damage to the home — it’s the damage to trust. These landlords wanted to help, and now feel they can never do it again.

Advice: It’s possible to be generous and still protect yourself. If you want to support vulnerable renters, consider working with housing programs that provide caseworkers or financial backing. Set clear expectations in your lease and follow through when things go wrong. Boundaries aren’t unkind — they’re necessary.

Final Thoughts

This story is tough to hear, especially when you know the heart behind it. But it’s not unique. Every year, good landlords leave the rental market because of experiences like this. And what’s left? Higher rents, fewer options and more barriers for those who need help the most.

Being a landlord means running a business, yes — but it’s also about serving people. With the right systems in place, you can do both. Learn from this story, protect yourself, and keep showing up with compassion, just with wiser tools in hand.

Post Views: 27